Lyrks
Lyrks
Lyrks
Cover Art

I Shouldn’t Be Surprised Lyrics by Gregg Edelman, Isabelle McCalla

Water for Elephants (Original Broadway Cast Recording)

2024

[MARLENA]
I shouldn't be surprised
I know what life can do
I wish it didn't do it
To you
I shouldn't be surprised
[MR. JANKOWSKI]
I shouldn't be surprised
[MARLENA]
I've seen it all before
[MR. JANKOWSKI]
I've seen it all before
[MARLENA & MR. JANKOWSKI]
I know I should have done much more
[MR. JANKOWSKI]
For cruelty
Where there should be kindness
Can only be
A kind of blindness
[MR. JANKOWSKI]
But I can see it all
[MARLENA]
I can see it all
[MR. JANKOWSKI]
The pain that's in your eyes
[MARLENA]
The pain that's in your eyes
[MR. JANKOWSKI]
I wish that I could be
Surprised

About “I Shouldn’t Be Surprised” by Gregg Edelman

Read the complete lyrics to "I Shouldn’t Be Surprised" by Gregg Edelman, Isabelle McCalla from the album "Water for Elephants (Original Broadway Cast Recording)" in 2024. On Lyrks you can follow along with the full text, explore the artist's discography, and discover related songs. The track is often categorized under Broadway, Musicals, Pop.

"I Shouldn’t Be Surprised" is performed by Gregg Edelman, Isabelle McCalla. from the album "Water for Elephants (Original Broadway Cast Recording)" in 2024 This page provides the full lyric text for fans who want to sing along, study the songwriting, or compare versions across releases. Lyrks organizes lyrics by artist and song slug so you can bookmark and share a stable URL. Music lyrics help listeners connect with emotion, narrative, and rhythm in a track. Whether you are learning English, researching a favorite chorus, or preparing for karaoke, having accurate line breaks and section labels (verse, chorus, bridge) makes the experience easier. We link to the official artist profile on Lyrks where available, including biography snippets, top songs, and chart placements when we have that data. If you enjoy "I Shouldn’t Be Surprised", explore more songs by Gregg Edelman, Isabelle McCalla using the links below. Chart and trending pages on Lyrks highlight what listeners are searching for this week. For copyright or correction requests, see our DMCA and contact pages.

View all songs and biography for Gregg Edelman · Trending lyrics · Billboard Hot 100

Frequently asked questions

"I Shouldn’t Be Surprised" is credited to Gregg Edelman, Isabelle McCalla. Songwriting credits may include additional writers listed on the release; check the credits section on this page for linked collaborators.

"I Shouldn’t Be Surprised" appears on "Water for Elephants (Original Broadway Cast Recording)" in 2024.

Visit the Gregg Edelman, Isabelle McCalla artist page at /artist/gregg-edelman for biography, popular tracks, and links to more lyric pages.